April 16, 2024


Built Business Tough

Medicare Advantage, consolidation drove healthcare insurer trends in 2021

Image: FG Trade/Getty Images

It was challenging to forecast development strains for the payer and wellbeing insurance coverage sector in 2021, largely because of persistent uncertainties owing to the COVID-19 pandemic. Client habits has turn out to be more unpredictable, treatment versions and offerings are changing and payers are adapting to a planet that is evolving fast and in sudden methods.

A single factor that has been rendered really unpredictable by the virus is the economical wellbeing of the nation’s key insurers, which soared all through the preliminary waves of the pandemic in 2020 but then settled again down to earth towards the stop of that calendar year. In 2021, insurers still posted primarily sizeable gains, but they have been much from the heights seen the former calendar year.

About the training course of the calendar year a several general themes started to arise. Insurers are plowing forward with electronic transformation initiatives, which include the enlargement of telehealth and digital wellbeing. Artificial intelligence and machine mastering have labored their way into the blend and fifty percent of payers now have innovation labs in the belief that electronic innovation will be the essential to the future.

Insurers also continued to consolidate in 2021, ensuing in hugely concentrated marketplaces that have drawn the interest of the federal governing administration, which seeks to control consolidation in a bid to empower individuals.

And then you will find Medicare Edge, which continues to expand it can be estimated MA options will go over more folks in 2022 than unique Medicare. A number of key insurers have taken observe, increasing their MA offerings in an work to capture more of the market place.

It can be been a wildly various calendar year in the payer room, but the way it has played out implies numerous of these development strains may well carry on into 2022 … and outside of.


COVID-19 continues to have an impact on each individual facet of American existence and the healthcare sector, and it can be driving traits in the payer planet as properly. At the HIMSS Point out of Health care function in June, Shreesh Tiwari, principal at ZS, mentioned the coronavirus has led to an improve in payer adoption of technologies and innovation.

Sixty-4 % of wellbeing insurance coverage executives report an accelerated adoption of electronic wellbeing initiatives this sort of as digital wellbeing. Yet another 53% report an acceleration in adoption of synthetic intelligence and machine mastering techniques, though forty two% mentioned COVID-19 has aided aid the adoption of value-based treatment preparations, according to Point out of Health care investigation by HIMSS, the father or mother company of Health care Finance Information.

COVID-19 has aided to drive improvements not just in technologies, but in attitude, Tiwari mentioned. The psychological and cultural limitations in terms of adoption are no more time becoming seen as issues.

About fifty percent of payers have an innovation lab and imagine AI and machine mastering will drive innovation forward. But 53% imagine healthcare startups will direct the way in driving major technologies innovation, Tiwari mentioned.

The governing administration also performs a essential position. Forty-6 % of payers imagine latest procedures and laws will aid innovation.

“Payers have tasted the fruits of innovation in the previous several months,” Tiwari mentioned at the time. “Interoperability is becoming seen as a essential driver in terms of taking care of issues coming out of the technologies infrastructure, knowledge infrastructure issues we have, carefully followed by knowledge privacy and knowledge stability.”

Not all of insurers’ electronic initiatives are likely flawlessly, nonetheless. Health options are revamping their electronic offerings in a bid to make sure you individuals, but these initiatives are sophisticated, a Deloitte study uncovered in June. Lots of options are battling to appropriately prioritize assignments, suggesting a deficiency of clear eyesight.

In point, about fifty percent of the 35 technologies leaders surveyed discovered this deficiency of eyesight as an impediment to these ongoing electronic transformation initiatives. 

Consumers are the ones largely impacted, as customer-going through platforms have manufactured the the very least progress. A very little over fifty percent of respondents, 57%, mentioned they’re still in the process of advancing these plans, though the remainder have not however started but say they are going to do so within just the subsequent two years.

There are other locations that are lagging as properly. The study targeted on modernization initiatives of five technologies platforms – administrative, analytics, clinical, main, buyer assistance and engagement – and only two respondents mentioned they had modernized a single of individuals platforms.

Those people surveyed discovered cyber and facts stability as the amount two investment precedence just after enterprise intelligence. But they warned it could be costly to right cyber-connected errors, specially ones owning to do with cloud configuration. Baking in cybersecurity in DevOps from the outset could make for a more successful and resilient process.

The conclusions speak to the broader difficulty of individual engagement, which has been an ongoing problem for wellbeing options and insurers. A J.D. Energy 2020 U.S. Industrial Member Health Prepare analyze uncovered that 60% of privately insured U.S. wellbeing prepare associates mentioned they had not been contacted by their wellbeing prepare with assistance or facts connected to COVID-19, and almost fifty percent (forty eight%) mentioned their wellbeing prepare has not shown concern for their wellbeing considering that the pandemic commenced.

Health options have not received buyer centricity, as just 36% of industrial wellbeing prepare associates mentioned their wellbeing prepare functions in their best fascination “constantly” or “most of the time,” and just 25% mentioned they look at their wellbeing prepare as a reliable spouse in their wellbeing and wellness.

This deficiency of buyer-centric positioning resulted in an total satisfaction rating last calendar year for industrial wellbeing options of 719 on a 1,000-issue scale, among the lowest of all industries evaluated, according to J.D. Energy.


Medicare Edge enrollment continued to improve and many key insurers expanded their MA footprints. It can be turn out to be a warm market place for insurers heading into the new calendar year.

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Providers mentioned that in 2022, MA is projected to reach 29.5 million folks in contrast to 26.nine million enrolled in a Medicare Edge prepare in 2021. 

For numerous seniors, MA is the favored wellbeing insurance coverage because of its lower upfront every month prices and included rewards. Medicare Edge options will carry on to offer a vast vary of supplemental rewards in 2022, which include eyewear, listening to aids, both equally preventive and comprehensive dental rewards, accessibility to meals (for a restricted duration), over-the-counter objects, exercise rewards and worldwide unexpected emergency/urgent coverage. 

In addition, the percentage of options giving unique supplemental rewards for chronically unwell people today will improve from 19% to 25%.

An growing amount of Medicare Edge twin suitable unique demands options go over both equally Medicare and Medicaid products and services for folks who are dually suitable. In 2022, 295 options (in contrast to 256 in 2021), will go over all Medicare products and services, moreover Medicaid-covered behavioral wellbeing treatment or extended-expression products and services.

CMS will carry on to test the Section D Senior Financial savings Model for insulin for seniors in more than 2,a hundred options in 2022. This calendar year, over five hundred new Medicare Edge and Section D prescription drug options, as properly as two new pharmaceutical companies of insulin, are joining the product that lowers out-of-pocket investing.

Moreover, more than 1,000 Medicare Edge options will participate in the CMS Innovation Center’s Medicare Edge Worth-Centered Insurance coverage Style and design Model in 2022, which exams the outcome of giving a projected 3.7 million folks tailored rewards made to much better manage their disorders and address social demands from food items insecurity to social isolation. 

The VBID Model’s Hospice Profit Component, now in its next calendar year, will also be made available by a hundred and fifteen Medicare Edge options in portions of 22 states and U.S. territories. It delivers enrollees improved accessibility to palliative and integrated hospice treatment. 

To support with their Medicare prices, lower-profits seniors and older people with disabilities may well qualify to acquire economical aid from the Medicare Financial savings Applications. Only about fifty percent of suitable folks are enrolled, CMS mentioned.

Cigna is acquiring on on the act by increasing its MA options, escalating into 108 new counties and three new states – Connecticut, Oregon and Washington – which will improve its geographic presence by almost thirty%, the insurance provider mentioned in Oct.

As element of the enlargement, Cigna mentioned most latest consumers will pay out the identical or reduce rates, and promised that each individual market place will have at the very least a single $ quality prepare. Other rewards will include a social link application to combat loneliness, tailored options for folks with diabetic issues and incentives for annual wellness tests and other preventive treatment.

Cigna has improved its geographic presence in MA by 80% considering that 2019, the insurance provider mentioned. The company now features options in 477 counties throughout 26 states and the District of Columbia.

Centene, in the meantime, mentioned this calendar year it will be broadening its reach in the Medicare Edge room in 2022, increasing into 327 new counties and three new states: Massachusetts, Nebraska and Oklahoma.

In all, this signifies a 26% enlargement of Centene’s MA footprint, with the giving obtainable to a prospective forty eight million beneficiaries throughout 36 states. Now, Centene serves more than 1.1 million MA associates throughout 33 states.

In September, Centene also declared it would consolidate its latest Medicare brands, which include Allwell, Health Net, Fidelis Care, Trillium Edge, ‘Ohana Health Prepare and TexanPlus, less than a single unified manufacturer dubbed Wellcare.

In the meantime, UnitedHealthcare, which now has considerable market place command with its Medicare Edge options, will improve its foothold in the room by increasing its MA options in 2022, introducing a prospective 3.1 million associates and achieving ninety four% of Medicare-suitable individuals in the U.S.

Now, more than 7.3 million folks are now enrolled in UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare Edge options. The insurance provider mentioned the enlargement will emphasis on lowering prescription drug prices, and increasing rewards and the member expertise.

But though UnitedHealthcare has a significant foothold in the Medicare Edge room, it underwent scrutiny from the federal governing administration earlier this month, when the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Providers blocked 4 Medicare Edge options from enrolling new associates in 2022 because they didn’t commit the least threshold on professional medical rewards. Three UnitedHealthcare options and a single Anthem prepare failed to strike the required 85% mark three years in a row.

Medicare Edge options are required to commit a least of 85% of quality bucks on professional medical costs failure to do so for three consecutive years triggers the sanctions.

For UHC, the penalties utilize to its MA options in Arkansas, New Mexico and the Midwest, which encompasses Missouri, Kansas, Nebraska and Iowa. UHC options go over about 83,000 associates, and the Anthem prepare addresses about 1,two hundred associates. They are not able to offer decide on options to associates right until 2023, assuming they strike the 85% threshold subsequent calendar year – what is referred to as the professional medical loss ratio (MLR). If they fall short to strike the threshold for five years in a row, the governing administration will terminate the contracts.

UHC reps told Bloomberg that it missed the 85% benchmark in specified marketplaces in element because of individuals deferring professional medical treatment owing to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Humana also declared it would debut a new Medicare Edge PPO prepare in 37 rural counties in North Carolina in reaction to market place demand in the japanese element of the state. 


Health insurance provider consolidation has been an additional ongoing development – and a single the latest administration would like to see with tighter reigns.

An government purchase issued by President Joe Biden in July cracked down on clinic and wellbeing insurance coverage consolidations and other steps it mentioned decreases competitiveness and drives up rates. The 4 locations of healthcare specific are: prescription medicine, clinic consolidation, wellbeing insurance coverage consolidations and listening to aids.

Consolidation in the wellbeing insurance coverage sector has meant that numerous individuals have very little decision when it comes to picking insurers, the purchase mentioned. 

Biden directed the Section of Health and Human Providers to standardize prepare possibilities in the wellbeing insurance coverage marketplace so folks can comparison shop more very easily. Options made available on the exchanges are sophisticated by the different products and services made available and differences in deductibles, the purchase mentioned.

Rick Pollack, president and CEO of the American Hospital Affiliation, urged federal businesses at the time to emphasis on procedures that address competitiveness among industrial wellbeing insurers.

“In point, with industrial wellbeing insurance coverage options, almost three out of 4 marketplaces have been hugely concentrated in 2019 and the prime five premier insurers by itself command almost 50% of the market place. Studies have uncovered that when an insurance coverage market place is hugely concentrated, insurers reduce provider payments and do not move financial savings along to the customer.”

The consequences of consolidation in 2021 also extended to prescription medicine. Consolidation among standalone Medicare Section D prescription drug options was the root trigger of a 23% decline in offerings for 2022, according to conclusions released last month by the Kaiser Loved ones Foundation.

The typical Medicare beneficiary will have a decision of 23 stand-by itself prescription drug options (PDPs) in 2022, seven fewer PDP possibilities than in 2021, the knowledge showed. Even though the amount of PDP possibilities in 2022 is much reduce than the peak in 2007 – when there have been fifty six this sort of possibilities, on typical – there are still many standalone drug prepare possibilities, according to KFF.

The relatively substantial lower in the amount of PDPs for 2022 is mainly the outcome of consolidations of prepare offerings sponsored by Cigna and Centene, ensuing in the market place exit of three national PDPs from every single agency in every single area: all three of Cigna’s Convey Scripts PDPs and three of Centene’s 6 Wellcare PDPs. Section D sponsors are restricted to giving no more than three PDPs in every single area. 

This accounts for just over two hundred PDPs made available in 2021 that will no more time be made available in 2022. Enrollees in these consolidated options will be routinely switched to other options made available by the identical prepare sponsor, although they can opt for to swap into a various prepare all through the annual open enrollment interval.

The amount of firms sponsoring stand-by itself drug options has declined steadily over time, from more than 40 firms in 2010 and earlier years, dropping down below 25 firms beginning in 2015, and at sixteen firms in 2022. That’s reduce than in any other calendar year considering that Section D started. 

PDP enrollment is predicted to be concentrated in a tiny amount of firms in 2022, as it has been each individual calendar year. Centered on August 2021 enrollment, 8 out of 10 enrollees in 2022 are projected to be in PDPs operated by just 4 firms: CVS Health, Centene, UnitedHealth and Humana. All 4 firms offer PDPs in all 34 regions subsequent calendar year.

Despite these calendar year-to-calendar year improvements in prepare coverage and prices, as properly as improvements in beneficiaries’ wellbeing demands, a former KFF investigation uncovered that most Medicare beneficiaries did not assess options all through a latest open enrollment interval, and most Section D enrollees did not assess the coverage made available by their drug prepare to other drug options.

The figures are related throughout both equally Medicare Edge and conventional Medicare, with 68% of MA beneficiaries expressing they really don’t assess professional medical options, and seventy three% of individuals in conventional Medicare claiming the identical.

Twitter: @JELagasse
E-mail the author: [email protected]